Home
Home » Blogs » Skyla's blog

Rejection: A Perspective

February 16, 2009 by Skyla
Skyla's picture

Part of my job for the past year has been working in Acquisitions. This means that I distribute "slush" (or unsolicited manuscripts) to my readers, as well as take some myself. I coordinate all this, and then send out rejection letters, full read notices, and acceptances accordingly.

Whenever I have correspondence with writers, there's a chance I'll hear back from them. Sometimes it's direct, other times it's indirectly. See, there's this thing about the internet...if you say it publicly, someone will read it. I get daily google alerts on my name, links to my site, as well as Mundania's name (so I'll probably get an alert about this entry). I have the alert set up for Mundania because I often find reviews that way on blogs that I wouldn't already know about.

Of course, I also then see the messages, like, "OMG, yay, I got a full read!" or "Fuck, I got rejected!"

Here is the thing that I wish more people would keep in mind...yes, waiting sucks. Yes, rejections suck. Yes, we're really, really slow sometimes. Yes, I'm sure I'm very evil.

But yours isn't the only manuscript being considered, and acquisitions isn't my only job.

I'm now overseeing every aspect of book production (I don't do it all, I just oversee it). The reason why I'm now able to tell people what is happening with their book during all aspects of production, and why I'm able to keep them informed, is because I follow the book from the moment it's submitted until it's released (and afterward, actually). I schedule, I issue contracts, I send books for review, and the hundred other little things that being Senior Editor entails.

We receive hundreds--and sometimes thousands--of manuscripts during the brief months we're open to submissions. My readers work their asses off, and I do everything in my power to answer people promptly. But the primary job of a publisher is to publish the books they have, not to give feedback regarding unsolicited manuscripts.

I realize that if your manuscript has been sitting in slush for two months, or six months, or--god help me--a whole year, it REALLY sucks ass. And you don't get why they can't just hurry up and make a decision. Or, if they reject you, why they can't just tell you why.

Because YOURS isn't the only manuscript there. Even when it gets narrowed down to the final review with the acquisitions editors, there is new slush coming in, plus all of those manuscripts already contracted that are being seen through production. Editors are really, really, really busy. They're not evil. They're not trying to make your life difficult.

So you can also understand how we also don't have time to give feedback on novels submitted. IF you get anything other than the usual form rejection from me--something either encouraging you to resubmit after making changes, or a note about how we liked your writing and would love to see future work--that is a REALLY good thing. Out of the twelve hundred we received during the first half of last year, about eight hundred were rejected off the top. Of the remaining four hundred I sent out custom rejection letters to...under ten, that I can recall. So if you got one of those, that speaks really highly for your writing. Of course, half the time people just bitch back to me about it, so I don't know why I bother.

I have no idea why I'm posting this because 99% of the people who submit never bother researching who they're sending to (I saw a cover letter addressed to Elizabeth the other day...not sure who she is, but she's never worked at Mundania), so I don't expect any prospective authors to read this. But maybe other writer friends will, and they'll keep some perspective the next time they're awaiting a response from an editor.

  • authors
  • publishing
  • rejections
  • writing
  • Skyla's blog
  • Quote

Comments

#1 My saddest rejection story is

Elaine Corvidae's picture
February 16, 2009 by Elaine Corvidae

My saddest rejection story is when Baen took over three years to get back to me on a partial (3 chapters and a synopsis). Since they don't (or didn't in the early-mid 1990's--I haven't checked their submission policies since) take simultaneous submissions, that entire book actually sunk out of sight for me while I was waiting. I have no idea if I even have it on a disk I can read anymore. The really painful thing is when they finally sent the rejection, it was one of the only purely-form rejections I've ever received, without even a note scribbled in the corner.

  • reply
  • quote

#2 See, that's fucking

Skyla's picture
February 16, 2009 by Skyla

See, that's fucking insane.

Mundania had some things for over a year. I felt totally horrible about it, but we're doing what we can. After three years...nope.

And we DO take sim subs. And what do writers do? When I go to tell them that either a) they were rejected, or b) they're going on for a full read, I get a note back, "Oh, I sold that elsewhere, like three months ago." Um...thanks for telling us and wasting our time and money! If it's been a year, fine. If it's been three months, that's not cool. They go on my auto-reject list. So, in summary, I can understand why pubs go for no sim subs on FULL submissions. But not partials...that's nuts.

MP used to send out more of a critique when they rejected work, but they got bitched at so many times from angry authors that they stopped bothering. And now I have people who write back and say, "Can you pleeeease tell me why?" and I'm like, "Uh...no?" The odd time I've asked someone to rewrite and resubmit, they've often told me where to go. ;-) I have actually had a few where the authors resubmitted and thanked me for the help, which is nice, but so rare.

n/a
  • reply
  • quote

#3 we read them

February 16, 2009 by Anonymous

Don't worry. Some of us writers eventually find your blogs/advice. And we read it. Guidelines? Well...just kidding. Some of us read those too!!!

Thanks for some great posts. I'm enjoying going through them all.

  • reply
  • quote

#4 Yep, some do, and I'm

Skyla's picture
February 16, 2009 by Skyla

Yep, some do, and I'm infinitely grateful for it. :-) Sometimes I feel like I'm preaching to the choir, though--most of what I bitch about is common sense, and the authors who look for advice usually have plenty of sense to start with. ;-)

n/a
  • reply
  • quote

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <em> <strong> <cite> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

More information about formatting options

Comments are moderated. I have a strict policy of No Douchebaggery and/or Trolling. You're free to disagree with anything I say, but your comment may or may not see the light of day (depending on the content of your comment and my particular mood). Any blatant trolling is immediately deleted with the offender's ISP info added to a personal file called In Case of Trouble.

I go through comments as often as possible but receive a ton of spam, so please be patient if your non-douchebaggy comment hasn't gone through yet--if I don't know you, you're not on my auto-publish list so I have to check by hand. And if you're a troll with nothing better to do than try to pick a fight with me, for the love of god, at least learn how to fucking spell.

User login

  • Request new password

2012 Reading Challenge

2012 Reading Challenge
Skyla has

read 6 books toward her goal of 30 books.

hide
6 of 30 (20%)
view books


Follow this blog

Adrienne Jones
Angry Black Bitch
Bitch Magazine
Bitten By Books
Colleen Lindsay
Dina James
Elaine Corvidae
Evil League of Evil Writers
The Fat Nutritionist
Feministing
Hanging with Bells
Heather Petty
J. A. Saare
Julie Butcher
Kate Harding
Lilith Saintcrow
Melinda Skye
Mundania Press
My World...in words and pages
Sarah-Jane Lehoux
Seleste deLaney
Shayne Winters
Skye's Lair
Stop Honour Killings
Terrible Minds
Whedonesque
Wicked Little Pixie



Works in Process:

Solomon's Seal
10000 / 90000
(11.11%)

Oblivion (DOB #5)
0 / 90000
(0%)

Godless (Dessa bk 5)
14000 / 85000
(16%)

Ashes (Ashes bk 1)
26000 / 75000
(34%)

In Darkness Waits (Darkness bk 1)
22000 / 90000
(24.44%)

Jane (secret project)
0 / 90000
(0%)

Children of the Apocalypse 3

My Authors' Books:

Recent blog posts

  • New Release...Sort Of?
  • "My Sanctuary" Review and Interview with Sarah-Jane Lehoux
  • Uppity-Update + Signal Boost Request
  • Dear Readers: Thank You
  • Bunny Surgery Day
  • A day in the life of Skyla working at home....
  • Update: Bunny Cancer, Nancy Drew, & Job Upgrade
  • Bunny Cancer
  • Signal Boost
  • Happy Release Day to Aline Hunter (J.A. Saare) for Enemy Mine
more

Recent comments

  • Fundraising
    12 hours 38 min ago
  • Sending Get Well Vibes!
    18 hours 23 min ago
  • You do so much for people,
    22 hours 20 min ago
  • LOL! Thank you. And I do
    22 hours 22 min ago
  • Thank you for stopping
    22 hours 28 min ago
  • Wonderful! Wonderful review
    1 day 14 hours ago
  • Glad you got some good news
    1 day 14 hours ago
  • I'm having an awful day (test
    6 days 11 hours ago
  • Aww, you are having a good
    6 days 13 hours ago
  • Aww, she'll be back to hating
    1 week 1 day ago

Poll

Who should narrate the short story included with Lineage?:

target="_blank"> src="http://c.statcounter.com/4692646/0/3fd039e3/1/"
alt="drupal hit counter">